Maintained by Quincy Hall, CFP® · Last updated and reviewed

A practical guide to finding, organizing, and preserving the documents needed to evaluate a financial-planning engagement under the Advice-Only™ Verification Standard and Engagement Conformance Assessment.

What this guide does

This guide does not decide whether an engagement conforms. It helps you assemble the evidence that decision depends on.

The goal is not to collect every document connected with an advisor. It is to gather enough reliable evidence to reconstruct one specific engagement or bounded advice cycle: what was agreed, what information was available, how the advice was formed, what was delivered, when the work was completed, and what happened before and after that point.

Some limits to know up front. This guide does not authenticate documents, guarantee that a record is complete, uncover undisclosed relationships on its own, judge whether advice was technically correct, or produce a conformance finding. An assessment rests on the documents and information provided, and the validity of those documents is not independently authenticated.

Before you begin: who holds what

Evidence for an engagement sits in three places.

Who holds it Examples If you cannot get it
You, the client Agreement, invoices, emails, the plan, meeting summaries Search again; record it as not found
The advisor or firm Accounting and compensation records, referral logs, CRM and data-flow records, internal policies Request it, or record it as not available
The public record Form ADV and brochures, Form CRS, BrokerCheck, the firm’s website and archived pages Retrieve it and note the date you did

A record assembled by a client often cannot establish matters that turn on advisor-side records, such as compensation arrangements, referrals, and how client information was used. Where the record cannot establish them, the Assessment records insufficient evidence rather than assuming an answer.

If you are an advisor or firm, the records contain confidential client information. Work within your own files, remove identifying details before sharing anything outside the firm, and do not send client records to anyone without authorization. The Standard calls for authorization that identifies the recipient, the purpose, the records covered, and how long the authorization lasts.

1. Start with one engagement

Write down, in a few lines:

For an ongoing relationship, choose one advice cycle rather than treating years of contact as a single engagement. Version 1.0 assesses one completed engagement or a separately bounded advice cycle within an ongoing relationship.

If the engagement ended before Version 1.0 took effect, record both the engagement dates and the date you are assessing it. Version 1.0 did not govern the engagement when it was performed. A retrospective assessment reports whether the surviving record supports conformance with the cited version; it does not certify that the engagement complied with a standard that did not yet exist. Records made at the time carry primary weight. Later explanations can clarify ambiguity, but they cannot create an agreement, completion boundary, or disclosure that was required to exist at the time. The age or incompleteness of a record may make Unable to Determine more likely, but it does not relax the standard.

2. Set up the evidence folders

Create the folders first, then fill them. Assemble first; judge later. Do not set a document aside because it looks favorable or unfavorable.

Start with five. You do not need to fill all ten folders on day one. Begin with the planning deliverable, the signed agreement and its effective date, the disclosures you received, the communications around the engagement, and the invoices with the record of payment and completion. These five are a practical starting point for reconstructing the engagement. Additional records may be needed to evaluate commercial independence, referrals, implementation boundaries, and other criteria, so add the other folders when the engagement involved referrals, implementation, later services, or compensation questions the first five cannot settle.

 

Folder Look for What it can show
01 Agreements and scope Advisory agreement, engagement letter, proposal, written scope, amendments What was promised, and when it took effect
02 Fees and payment Fee schedule, quote, invoices, payment records How compensation worked and who paid
03 Client facts and assumptions Questionnaires, data requests, statements and source documents actually used, stated assumptions What information the advice rested on
04 Advice formation Analyses, scenarios, meeting notes How recommendations were reached and which alternatives were considered
05 Deliverables Interim outputs, final recommendations or plan What the client actually received
06 Communications Emails, texts, portal messages The chronology, and what was said when
07 Completion Completion notice, final-delivery message, closing invoice Where the advice cycle ended
08 Implementation and later services Account-opening, transfer, or trading records; later agreements Whether implementation began before completion, and whether later service was separate
09 Referrals and outside professionals Introductions and referral communications Referral or reciprocal relationships
10 Representations and disclosures Website and service descriptions, Form ADV and brochures, Form CRS where one applies, privacy notice, as they existed during the engagement What clients were told about compensation and implementation

For folder 10, a current web page or filing may differ from what existed then. Save dated copies and look for earlier versions where available. Form ADV is available through the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site, and BrokerCheck shows registration and employment history if the advisor ever held a brokerage registration.

Illustrative Sample Evidence Packet

The sample evidence packet below illustrates how records from a fictional financial-planning engagement can be organized, indexed, and evaluated. It includes illustrative engagement documents, an evidence index, a case chronology, and a reviewer walkthrough.

Download the complete sample evidence packet (ZIP)

You can also review selected documents individually:

Important limitation: This sample is illustrative, not a template for claiming conformity. Possessing similar documents does not establish that an engagement conforms to the Advice-Only™ Verification Standard. Verification depends on evaluating the evidence as a whole, including its relevance, reliability, completeness, consistency, and relationship to the engagement being assessed. The sample does not represent an actual engagement or an official conformance finding.

3. Use search and AI tools to find the record

Email search, file search, and AI assistants can cut retrieval time substantially. Useful searches:

AI can help locate and organize evidence. It cannot authenticate documents, establish that evidence it did not find never existed, show that the collected record is complete, or decide that an engagement conforms.

Financial records carry account numbers and personal identifiers. Redact before using any AI tool, and use only tools whose data handling you have checked. Advisors should use only tools their firm’s policies permit.

4. Build the chronology

The same document can mean different things depending on when it existed. Mark the date of each event below, and write “not found” rather than guessing.

  1. First substantive contact
  2. Agreement effective
  3. Fee agreed
  4. Client information obtained
  5. Analysis performed
  6. Recommendations developed
  7. Interim outputs delivered
  8. Final delivery
  9. Completion boundary
  10. Later implementation discussions
  11. Any new, separate agreement
  12. Implementation activity

Pay particular attention to what happened before the agreement was effective. Agreement Before Advice (Criterion 1 under Version 1.0) asks whether an effective written agreement was in place before individualized advice began, so messages sent before the agreement, including ones describing what a first meeting would cover, can matter as much as anything written afterward.

Boundary evidence

Ordinary document gathering does not naturally focus on where the advice ended. Look specifically for:

5. Look for economic, referral, and access connections

Search beyond invoices for:

A relationship that existed is something to record. Whether it influenced the assessed engagement is a question for the Assessment, not for this guide.

6. Handle conflicting and missing evidence

Conflicts. Do not resolve a contradiction by choosing whichever document looks more authoritative. Keep both. Examples:

Weighing is the evaluator’s job, not yours. Evidence is weighed for relevance, authenticity, contemporaneity, independence, completeness, and consistency. Independent or system-generated records ordinarily carry greater weight for facts within their competence, but no category automatically controls. That is why originals and timestamps matter.

Missing evidence. “I couldn’t find it” is not the same as “it did not happen.” Record missing evidence as missing, not as a favorable or unfavorable fact. It can affect whether the record is sufficient and may ultimately lead to an Unable to Determine finding.

The Standard treats two kinds of absence differently. Where a criterion requires that a record or documented boundary existed at the relevant time, such as a written agreement before advice began, its absence can support a Not Met finding. Where a missing record merely prevents reliable reconstruction of an underlying fact that might otherwise have occurred, the result is Insufficient Evidence. Which applies is the evaluator’s decision. Your job is to record what you searched, what you found, and what you could not locate.

Some questions turn on something not having happened: no referral, no commission, no client data shared. Documents often cannot show that either way. Record what you searched and what you found. An evaluator may need corroboration beyond documents.

7. Preserve provenance and keep an evidence index

Keep the original filename, document date, sender and recipient, the original email thread and its attachments, the source location, the version, and any relevant timestamp. Keep originals rather than pasted text.

If you redact, remove account numbers, credentials, Social Security numbers, medical information, and unrelated personal details. Keep the untouched original, and log what you removed and why.

Index each item using the same columns as the Professional Evidence Inventory in the Assessment, so rows carry straight across.

 

ID Record / date / source Primary / related criteria Redaction — category / reason / limits a criterion? Reliability, conflicts & limits
E-01 Email, 8/12/26, advisor to client: final-plan delivery Completion of Agreed Work (Criterion 12); Documented Completion or Advice-Cycle Boundary (Criterion 14) Client contact details removed States the agreed plan was delivered; need to determine whether scenario analysis was still outstanding
E-02 Advisor’s accounting records for the engagement period No Implementation-Linked Economic Benefit (Criterion 6) None Not available: held by the advisor; requested 1/2/26
E-03

An organized index does not show that the record is complete. Add a row for each record you know exists but could not obtain, marked “not available” with the reason. Note anything you were asked to leave out and any limits on your access to advisor-side information. The evaluator takes those limits into account when deciding whether the evidence is sufficient.

8. Check whether the record is ready

Map the record to the 21 criteria only after it is substantially assembled. You do not need 21 separate packages; one document can support several criteria. In the Assessment, record for each criterion the supporting evidence, conflicting evidence, missing evidence, and anything that needs evaluator judgment.

The record is ready when you can:

If you cannot, you can still proceed, because the Assessment has a way to record insufficient evidence. But a gap found now costs less than one found halfway through.

9. Three ways to proceed

Any qualified professional may apply the Standard, and no assessment requires approval from AdviceOnly.info.

Next steps